10 Comments

  1. steve l on September 17, 2022 at 12:28 am

    everyone being all critical about ridiculous things and i’m just wondering if there’s a video on the construction of the frame itself?

  2. Big Swifty on September 17, 2022 at 12:37 am

    Dye stains do NOT have a "more even pigmentation" (at the 2:05 mark). Dyes have NO pigmentation. They are dyes. They are not pigments. It’s either/or, dye or pigment. Dyes sit in the wood cell, pigments are granular products that sit ON TOP of the surface. It’s the difference between getting a tan vs. applying brown makeup.

    What you should have said and maybe what you meant to say was that dyes have a more even coloring. In that this video is made by a woodworking magazine, your copy editors should have caught this wrong information regarding what a dye stain is and what it isn’t. Wood finishing is hard enough for novices. Getting the terminologies and the lexicon mixed up, as was done egregiously in this video, makes it even harder for neophyte wood finishers. Vernacular matters. Wrong information is BAD information. Not acceptable.

  3. VAZZ 22 on September 17, 2022 at 12:44 am

    I appreciate this tutorial

  4. Learner-Learns on September 17, 2022 at 12:52 am

    Great lighting! Fancy camera work! Dolly shots through the doorway, (several times becomes distracting) boom shots, focus, auto-fades, etc. Overall effect is mesmerizing without the harsh stroboscopic shocks of commercial formal features, but constant motion is unnecessary and slightly annoying. 

    Good audio balance between background music and narration. Kenny’s voice is much more tolerable with this nice recording: Close mic’ed in a booth with a decent mic, EQ and compression. He sounds musical, melodic, pleasant, less whiney. A+ ! Great improvement! 

    Love the fawn grey background with faux timber-frame accents. This set is easy on the eyes!  Most shops will never be so neat. Still, it’s a pleasing backdrop that does a good job promoting the fantasy of quiet craftsmanship from a bygone age.

    Someone at FW is paying attention to production value! Nice. Taunton must be trying to reestablish market dominance with "Avid fans" in this "Final Cut." Good Luck Fellas!

    As always, the Taunton writing /editing style is excellent, concise and casual.
    Good grammar promotes understanding, especially when narration is produced so professionally.

    Suggestions: Work on a larger vocabulary of camera tricks, or just use them less. Content is the new King. Like good musical technique, production technique is a means to an end, not the end itself. 

    Keep the new mic and mic technique. That will help everyone of course, but Kenny’s narration is greatly improved and those techniques bring out his best. 

    Perhaps a different exterior mat wold help the illusion. That endless nascent autumn is soothing, but static. It seems a bit "Stepford-ish" after two or three videos. 

    Good work! I hope my passive / aggressive observations are taken in the helpful humorous spirit from whence they came. 

  5. James Webb on September 17, 2022 at 12:57 am

    This is beautiful work – I’ve watched this several times over the past couple of years to be sure I’d have it right when it came time to do the woodwork in my new house. That time has come! It now strikes me that the top coat process is an enormous undertaking for an entire house (wainscot, base, crown, doors, door and window trim, chair rail, etc.) What are your thoughts on Arm-r-seal satin or a mix of satin and semi-gloss to achieve something like your work?

  6. James Wheeldon on September 17, 2022 at 12:57 am

    Thanks! that was a awesome how to on achieving a great finish.

  7. Slawomir Ostrowski on September 17, 2022 at 12:59 am

    i remember the same video from over a year ago

  8. gary24752 on September 17, 2022 at 12:59 am

    Would have been nice if you had said what products you were using

  9. Adam Wolven on September 17, 2022 at 1:01 am

    Great method. I love the Robert Lang book on the original Greene and Greene methods – awesome read. But the dye is a nice alternative to oxidizing with potassium dichromate. Thanks FineWoodworking!

  10. Randy Marder on September 17, 2022 at 1:16 am

    this is an excellent produced video, unfortunately this is not even close to the original Greene and Greene finishes used with the obvious modern oil based urethane used in the video  Even when you substitute oil base varnish the approach is wrong.  The original finishes were hand rubbed with multiple coats, built up with a custom blended oil mixture.  As each coat is applied the natural color of the wood becomes deeper and richer in tone .  I do agree this is a simple recipe for a good modern finish on new work, but i would not recommend this finish for antiques and your collectables

Leave a Comment